Preet Bharara Was Fired After Defying Jeff Sessions' Order to Resign as US Attorney

Photo: AP
Photo: AP

Preet Bharara announced on Saturday that he’d been fired from his position as US Attorney for the Southern District of New York, which includes Manhattan, where Donald Trump used to reside and his wife still does. Bharara was fired just hours after he refused to comply with Attorney General Jeff Sessions’ order on Friday for 46 US attorneys (all the ones that had been nominated by the Obama administration) to resign, effective immediately.


Bharara is a progressive attorney known for being a relatively aggressive prosecutor of corruption on Wall Street, and you might also remember as the guy who issued a subpoena for Anthony Weiner’s cell phone. The former US Attorney wrote that he’d been let go on his Twitter feed, which he only set up two weeks ago, perhaps in anticipation of this very moment.


Is this standard behavior for a new administration? According to Buzzfeed News’ Chris Geidner and Zoe Tillman, new presidents tend to replace most US attorneys, but usually not so quickly, and not before successors have been nominated or confirmed. One of the attorneys who was asked to resign told Buzzfeed News anonymously that he didn’t receive any advance notice that resignations would be asked for so soon, nor did any of his colleagues, as far as he was aware.

Though Sessions officially requested the resignations, it was the president who reportedly directed him to do so. According to Bharara, Trump asked him during a meeting at his Manhattan tower in late November to stay on as a US Attorney. New York Senator Chuck Schumer also said in a statement on Saturday that Trump had called him in November and “assured me he wanted Mr. Bharara to continue to serve as US Attorney for the Southern District.”

Bharara’s office had been in the process of investigating corruption allegations in relation to two New York politicians, the New York Times reports:

“[Bharara’s] office is preparing to try a group of former aides and associates of Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo in a wide-ranging bribery and bid-rigging case and has been investigating Mayor Bill de Blasio’s campaign fund-raising as part of an inquiry into whether he or other officials exchanged official acts for political donations.”


The Times suggested on Friday that, while Bharara will presumably be temporarily succeeded by his deputy Joon H. Kim, Marc Mukasey is one of a few names being floated to replace him. Mukasey is the son of a former Bush administration attorney general and works at the same law firm as Rudy Giuliani. I guess there’s nothing intrinsically good about having a job!

This is a developing story and will be updated if and when Trump writes something inflammatory about it on Twitter.

contributing writer, nights

Share This Story

Get our newsletter


The distinction so many of the online reactions to the dismissals seem to be missing (and that I’m really glad this article makes note of) is that dismissals of this sort are completely normal for incoming administrations (former Presidents Bill Clinton and George W. Bush dismissed similar numbers of US Attorneys), but dismissing so many with little to no notice--and no replacements on-deck—absolutely is not normal.

My disagreements with this administration are many, varied, and at times vociferous—but the one thing I’ve never been able to get any of the Trump supporters I know to reconcile is the fact that this dude continually cleans out entire government apparati without having anyone waiting in the wings to keep the cogs turning.

The most common response I get when I ask about firing/dismissing significant chunks of staff without ready replacements is, “Well, he’s cleaning house!”

Sure. The problem is that an empty house is an unguarded house—and while invasion of said house might not be in the immediate offing, the fact is that an empty domicile invites squatters, some of whom may well refuse to leave when better-prepared tenants come calling.

TL;DR: I despise the Trump administration for myriad reasons (the xenophobia, the anti-Semitism, the installation of open racists in cabinet and top-government positions, etc), but I just cannot understand what the end-game is in gutting government offices without ready replacements, apart from willful destabilization—which is the sort of thing an angry child does when no one’s patting them on the head just for existing.