Elizabeth Warren Privately Apologized to Cherokee Nation For DNA Test

Illustration for article titled Elizabeth Warren Privately Apologized to Cherokee Nation For DNA Test
Image: Getty

After refusing to admit any wrongdoing for months, Massachusetts Sen. and rumored 2020 presidential candidate Elizabeth Warren has quietly apologized to the Cherokee Nation for claiming native ancestry via a DNA test last fall.

Advertisement

The Intercept reports:

On the campaign trail, she has noted repeatedly that she does not claim citizenship in any tribe nor was she trying to.

But she’s quietly since gone a step further. Warren has been in touch with Cherokee Nation leadership, apologizing for furthering confusion over issues of tribal sovereignty and citizenship and for any harm her announcement caused, two sources with knowledge of her overture said. The Warren campaign declined to comment.

“Senator Warren has reached out to us and has apologized to the tribe,” Cherokee Nation’s executive director of communications Julie Hubbard told The Intercept. “We are encouraged by this dialogue and understanding that being a Cherokee Nation tribal citizen is rooted in centuries of culture and laws not through DNA tests. We are encouraged by her action and hope that the slurs and mockery of tribal citizens and Indian history and heritage will now come to an end.”

Advertisement

In October, Warren took Donald Trump’s bait, responding to his repeated “Pocahontas” jabs by releasing a nearly six-minute video about DNA test that found mostly European ancestry with a trace of indigenous DNA “in the range of 6-10 generations ago.” From this, she claimed Native American heritage, and interviews with relatives and former professors, described how this ancestry impacted her family and career.

As Dr. Kim TallBear, an Associate Professor on the Faculty of Native Studies at University of Alberta and member of the Sisseton-Wahpeton Oyate tribe, told Jezebel, DNA tests cannot prove Native American ancestry “because it’s not ancestry alone that constitutes what it is to be a tribal member or even a Native American more broadly, at least from the point of view of Native Americans.” Warren’s claim perpetuated stereotypes about Native Americans and further erased their experiences.

Writer and activist Rebecca Nagle, a member of the Cherokee Nation, criticized Warren’s apology, saying “without a public apology this private phone call falls flat and rings hollow.”

Advertisement

“The widely publicized DNA test debacle created confusion about tribal citizenship, Native identity and race that directly harmed Native rights. Warren has a duty to clear up the confusion she caused. That can only be done through a public, clear, and transparent statement,” she wrote.

Advertisement

Prachi Gupta is a senior reporter at Jezebel.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

universerunner
A Lantern of Hope

Writer and activist Rebecca Nagle, a member of the Cherokee Nation, criticized Warren’s apology, saying “without a public apology this private phone call falls flat and rings hollow.”

On the one hand, I see what Nagle means. On the other, a public apology would have been pounced on by some people as a publicity stunt. To me, a private apology seems more sincere, but it’s the Cherokees’ — like Nagle — views on the subject that matter.